The Cost of Discipleship

The Cost of Discipleship – A Reflection with Archbishop William Temple

(For the University of Winchester on 6 Nov 2024 - the Commemoration of William Temple)

Scripture: Luke 14:25-33

In today’s passage, Jesus speaks about the cost of discipleship in stark terms: “Whoever does not carry their cross and follow me cannot be my disciple” (Luke 14:27). For those of us in academic settings, where reason, analysis, and pursuit of knowledge are daily practices, these words are a call to reflect deeply on the nature of commitment. Jesus is asking us not merely for belief, but for an allegiance that may require the sacrifice of everything we hold dear.

Archbishop William Temple, a towering figure in 20th-century Anglican thought, provides an invaluable perspective on this radical call. Temple is particularly known for linking Christian faith with a responsibility to act in society.  Notably, he was influential in the political debates which led to the creation of a welfare state, and the National Health Service, after the Second World War.  Temple’s perspective encourages us to apply our intellect and talents in service to the common good, not just personal advancement. His work reminds us that Christianity is not a private faith, nor a comfortable affiliation, but a way of life that requires an alignment between what we believe and how we live.

If you’ll allow me, I have three areas of focus I’d like to explore briefly.  First, I want to to ask what radical discipleship looks like.  Secondly, I’d like to ask how we can align our faith with our intellect.  And finally, I’d like to explore what Sacrifice and Solidarity with the Marginalized looks like.

1. A Vision of Radical Discipleship

William Temple’s writings often highlight the societal implications of the Christian life. In his influential work Christianity and Social Order, Temple makes the case that Christianity must extend beyond the walls of the church to transform the wider world. This notion complements Jesus’ call to discipleship in Luke 14:25-33. Temple asserts that a Christian’s devotion should not only be personal but should radiate outward, impacting communities and systems of society.

Temple’s vision of radical discipleship means that counting the cost, as Jesus commands, includes not just personal sacrifices but the courage to challenge injustice in society. In a university context, where ideals of fairness, truth, and progress are upheld, Temple’s insights remind us that discipleship demands more than intellectual assent; it demands action. For Temple, if our faith is real, it will lead us to care deeply about the conditions of others’ lives, to strive for justice, and to make sacrifices for the sake of the oppressed and marginalized.

Temple’s thought encourages students and academics to reflect on how our intellectual pursuits might serve the common good, extending the meaning of discipleship to embrace social, economic, and ethical concerns. This is costly because it may require us to question our assumptions, to make decisions that prioritize others’ needs over our own success, and to advocate for truth and justice, even when it is inconvenient or unpopular.

2. The Alignment of Faith and Intellect

One of the great challenges for university students and academics is finding harmony between intellectual rigor and faith. In his writings, Temple held that faith and intellect are not opposites but partners. He argued that the search for truth, wherever it may lead, is ultimately a search for God, for “all truth is God’s truth.” His theological framework sees God not only as the ultimate truth but as the foundation for all truth we seek to understand in every discipline—be it science, philosophy, or literature.

Temple’s perspective can help us understand Jesus’ command to "count the cost" as an invitation to examine not only our hearts but also our minds. For Temple, the intellect is a sacred gift to be used in service to God and others. When we commit ourselves to discipleship, it means dedicating our studies, research, and teaching to principles of truth, justice, and compassion. This may mean using our academic platform to speak out against unfair practices, whether in research ethics, social policies, or educational access.

In a society that often values intellectual prestige and individual accomplishment, Temple’s view of discipleship challenges us to ask hard questions: How do my studies contribute to the greater good? Does my research serve the common welfare, or merely my personal ambition? The cost of discipleship, therefore, includes aligning our intellect with our faith, and sometimes choosing paths of scholarship or professional action that might be less profitable or popular but more faithful.

3. Sacrifice and Solidarity with the Marginalized

Archbishop Temple was deeply concerned with the well-being of society’s most vulnerable. He argued that “the church exists primarily for those who are outside it,” reflecting the outward focus of a true disciple. This idea aligns with Jesus’ message in Luke 14:27 about “carrying the cross.” For Temple, carrying our cross means standing in solidarity with the marginalized, advocating for economic fairness, and challenging structures that perpetuate inequality.

In academic life, where resources, access, and prestige can create significant divides, Temple’s reflections push us to consider how we might “carry our cross” in a context that values competition and individual success. Discipleship might mean choosing to use our privilege to support others, to create opportunities for underrepresented voices, and to uplift the marginalized within our institutions and communities. As Temple writes, “Social welfare is rooted in a theology of incarnation”—a theology that sees God as deeply concerned with the material and social realities of all people.

Temple’s emphasis on social responsibility speaks to us in concrete terms: our faith requires us to live sacrificially, even in our educational and professional pursuits. We must be willing to consider how we can use our influence to advocate for policies that protect the vulnerable, to ensure access to resources and knowledge, and to build inclusive communities. This type of cross-bearing might not come with public recognition, but it is, in Temple’s words, an offering to God and to our neighbour.

Conclusion: A Call to Transformative Discipleship

As we reflect on Jesus’ words in Luke 14:25-33, informed by William Temple’s teachings, we are called to consider how discipleship might transform every area of our lives, including our academic pursuits. The cost is high, but the reward—participating in God’s vision of justice, love, and truth—is profound.

Temple’s perspective challenges us not only to “count the cost” of discipleship in our personal lives but to see it as a vocation that demands integrity, courage, and compassion in all spheres. For university students and academics, this means thinking critically about how our studies, our research, and our influence can contribute to a world that reflects God’s love and justice. It calls us to be both scholars and servants, to let our intellect be guided by a faith that seeks the well-being of all.

In a world that often prizes self-interest, Temple’s vision of discipleship is a reminder that following Jesus is countercultural and costly. Yet it is precisely this radical commitment that Jesus invites us to embrace—a commitment that seeks not only personal growth but the transformation of society in the name of love and truth. May you have the courage to answer this call, bearing the cross with hope, humility, and a vision of the Kingdom that Temple so passionately believed in.